So a decision has been made regarding the front of the house:
We're going with Ladybug, the color on the right. The color on the left (Barn) is just a little too pink. It'll be at least a satin finish, if not a high gloss and the side door will get a coat too. I'm thinking eventually the shutters will be painted black and it will all look oh so great.
And yes, I'll be removing the pine wreath before March rolls around.